... Eleuthera because of the location of the piece of real estate I have found. It is situated on the north shore, north of Central Eleuthera, near Driftwood Beach.
It is a beach front lot and has a spectacular view of the vast, wide open Atlantic Ocean. That is my main reason for Eleuthera being my best Caribbean island.
I also like the cliffs along the north shore of Eleuthera, and the endless water of the sea.
Also, Eleuthera is sparsely populated enough to be a very quiet and sleepy place to live. It just looks like a wonderful place to live.
Unfortunately I have never been there, but hope to go very soon. As Pierre says on http://www.discover-eleuthera-bahamas.com/rainbow-property-pierre-gigi.html I should visit the island first before making any decisions. So yes, Eleuthera would certainly seem to be the place for me.